Grading Economics
Some good news on the grading freeze: PSA's backlog is shrinking. As of July 1, 2026, the active queue is down to about 12 million cards, and if the pace holds, the cheap Value tiers could reopen around October. Before you plan your submissions around that date, though, look at the number that is not in any tracker: the cards sitting on your desk, and everyone else's, waiting for exactly that moment. That shadow backlog is the reason the October timeline is shakier than it looks.
PSA reported the active backlog down to roughly 12 million cards, from nearly 14 million on June 9. The company grades around 2 million cards a month and says an all-hands push may lift that by about 20%, to roughly 2.4 million. Value tiers are expected to return once the backlog falls to about 5 million.
Do the arithmetic and October checks out, with one giant asterisk. Clearing 12 million down to 5 million means burning through 7 million cards. At 2.4 million a month, that is just under three months from early July, so an October target. But that projection, in SI's own framing, assumes new submissions have "dropped to near zero." That assumption is the whole ballgame, and it will not survive contact with the reopening.
The 12 million figure counts cards already in PSA's building. It does not, and cannot, count the cards people are deliberately holding back: the stacks in closets, the "to grade" piles on desks, the boxes set aside the moment Value got paused. Value was the highest-volume tier, the default cheap lane for bulk submitters, so when it closed, a huge amount of would-be volume did not disappear. It just went on hold.
You can even see the shadow in the official numbers. The reason the backlog is falling is that new submissions have dropped below normal while Value is closed. That suppressed volume is not gone. It is the same cards, waiting. Nobody can put a real figure on it, and anyone who quotes one is guessing. But we know two things for certain: it is large, because Value carried the most volume, and it is coiled, because it is all pointed at a single trigger.
Here is the trap. The projection assumes submissions stay near zero right up until reopening. But the act of reopening is the thing that ends the near-zero period. The moment Value comes back, the held-back cards come off the desks, and the queue that took months to draw down can refill in weeks.
This is not a hypothetical. It already happened in reverse. When PSA announced the pause, collectors rushed to get cards in under the wire and the queue jumped from about 10 million to nearly 14 million in a matter of days. Latent demand in this hobby is enormous and it moves fast, in whatever direction the news points. Reopening points it straight back at the queue.
| Path | What it assumes | When Value realistically reopens |
|---|---|---|
| PSA's projection | New submissions stay near zero | Around October 2026 |
| The reflexive reality | Held-back cards flood in as reopening nears | Slips later, or reopens then re-clogs |
So treat "Value is back in October" as a best case that depends on the shadow backlog politely staying home. It will not. The likeliest outcomes are a later reopening than the clean math suggests, or a reopening that is quickly swamped, with turnaround times right back where they are now.
The decision this forces is the same one we keep coming back to, just with the timing risk made explicit.
The headline is that the backlog is shrinking, and that is real. The fine print is that the number you can see is smaller than the number you cannot. Plan around the one on your desk, not just the one on the tracker.
The Report Card turns an ask price, your comps, and the pop report into expected value, a max-buy price, and an honest confidence range. Every call we make with it is logged publicly, timestamped, before the outcome exists.
Get early access See the public track record →